Moving on to the next act of America means will require breaking up with the politics that keep bringing us back to the same place.
Following the oligarchic devastation of the Trump regime’s first two years in office (trashing public programs, starting a wildly unpopular and destructive war, and engaging in rank, open corruption), the historic midterms were a clear mandate for the Democrats to enforce accountability and pursue Left policies.
Yet, neither has a chance without intense public pressure and organizing. That organizing must aim both to keep those elected officials accountable and to build independent movements or political parties in the interim period.
That’s because the Democrats have already signaled, yet again, their fundamental unwillingness to independently reform even before officially taking their new offices, managing to fail to advance Pete Hegseth’s impeachment and, even more tellingly, voting to overwhelmingly approve Hakeem Jeffries as House Speaker despite profound opposition from the very voters who just elected them.
Democrats have done this while they and their sycophants in the press have made particularly note of Jeffries as the first Black speaker, a hollow victory for representation dangled out in front of the gullible at a time when at least 60% of Americans can’t afford a $1,000 emergency and Black populations continue to be disproportionately impoverished.
Jeffries bid was supported by an astonishing 251 lawmakers, including once-hopeful progressives such as Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, using the weak excuse that ‘nobody else was running.’ (She has a lot on her mind, after all, as she is now purportedly eyeing a 2028 presidential run and wouldn’t want to take any risks that might signal a sincere support for working class people…not that she has a history of doing so.)
Similarly, New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani supported Hakeem Jeffries in 2025, support he would later reaffirm in the leadup to Wednesday’s vote. While Mamdani has been a more effective progressive policy advocate than Ocasio-Cortez, his support of Jeffries was one of the first signs for many of his most ardent supporters that he, once plugged into the Democratic party machine, would only do so much to deviate.
And, indeed, if you don’t think new Democratic party representatives are aggressively intimidated into towing the line, you’d be wrong: Representative-elect Don Leonard, a Democrat who flipped a Republican seat in Ohio, has spoken out that senior party leaders warned they would inflict “living hell” on him if he opposed Jeffries for House speaker.
Ultimately, Jeffries was approved by all but 11 during Wednesday’s internal caucus vote. Those 11 included 7 newly elected House Democrats: Democratic Reps.-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier (N.Y.), Adam Hamawy (N.J.), Frederick Haynes (Texas), Melat Kiros (Colo.), Donavan McKinney (Mich.), Chris Rabb (Pa.) and Claire Valdez (N.Y.).
In a statement by the minority group, they appealed to the plain-as-day mandate given to them by voters: “Whether on Medicare for All, stopping ICE terror, getting money out of politics, or ending the genocide in Gaza, our constituents sent us to Congress with a mandate on these issues…”
And so, here we are again: another ‘Blue Wave,’ the desperate hope of an abused working class, and no signal from Democratic leadership that there is any intent to respond to their needs.
I’ve lived long enough to see this American electoral political cycle play out three or four different times in my adult life. It’s the “accountability flip-flop” that occurs every time the fickle and under-informed American electorate gets angry at one party just to yet again commit themselves to the same mistakes they’ve made time and time again in the past.
The cycle is ever the same: A) the election of a new president or congress is followed by B) their inevitable refusal to help the working class or advance the policies they care about (“failure” would be the incorrect concept here, as it implies a sincere attempt) followed then by C) the flipping of the congress or presidency in an attempt to right the damage to working people that just occurred. Because it’s a cycle, (A) is always effectively (C) and vice versa.
However, every time this “flip” occurs, every time the Democrats yet again have that opportunity to right the wrongs of their Republican opponents, we can see that they fail in ways so spectacular as to create an electoral window for the oligarchic devastation that comes next at the hands of their Republican shadows.
In a very real and clear way, the Democrats refusal to simply throw the working class a bone or two, let alone create the type of reforms people actually need, allows for overtly fascistic figures like Trump, Bannon, Kushner and the Evangelical death cultists surrounding them to rise.
This is really not some abstract political theory or 4D chess. Indeed, the causal chain could scarcely be laid barer at this juncture: the Democrats negligence causes extreme damage when their Republican opponents fill the resultant space. Just as importantly, they themselves cause extreme damage with their own corporatist, imperialist policies.
The way the Democratic Party has effectively absorbed and dissipated genuine Leftist political grievance is to-date a wildly successful con job that has distracted voters from autonomously pursuing their own interests as working class people for far too long.
What they often choose to do, or not do, is not a 'failure,' a shortcoming of effort, skill, or resources. They know what they’re doing. Joe Biden knew what he was doing when he broke his most important, impactful domestic campaign promises and coordinated with Israel to commit a genocide of Palestinians.
He was indifferent when his administration caused mass disillusionment within the Democratic base to such as a degree as to hand Trump both the popular and electoral vote, and even expressed bitterness that the party did not stick with his obviously doomed reelection efforts.
If the Democrats would but actually serve the working class they so purport to care about, they would face no electoral challenges whatsoever. But Democrats would rather lose to Republicans than face actual working class accountability and elect truly progressive leadership.
Yet, they never face accountability. Indeed, if anything has been proven of late in American politics, it is that we appear to live in an era that is fully post-accountability.
These “flips” are convenient to power for a number of reasons, but none moreso than their combined ability to 1) keep accountability low, so that no one party is in power long enough for their voters to become thoroughly disillusioned; and 2) continue the ‘drama,’ the theater, the abuse cycle, the latest season in the horror-comedy that is American life.
It’s a performance Trump knows well and has mastered as well as could have ever been expected for one who so obviously has no business in government, yet it is through his victory that we can most easily see the galling machinations of the deceit, the ongoing simulation of politics that is the two-party, inverted totalitarian electoral system we so thoroughly enjoy in America.
Hanna Arendt, writing on totalitarian societies, described our level of near-total dysfunction as the consequences of non-stop deceit on the part of power, of a kind of derealization and disorientation that occurs in the mind of the democratic electorate: "The result of a consistent and total substitution of lies for factual truth is not that the lies will now be accepted as truth, and the truth be defamed as lies, but that the sense by which we take our bearings in the real world…is being destroyed."
That sense of what is real, of our bearings, contributes to the impression that American political life is a show, entertainment, theater. And while it has become common to describe American political dynamics as such, I argue that when one looks square at the totality of the dysfunction, ‘theater’ breaks down in its utility as an appropriate metaphor.
In other words, American politics is not merely a kind of theater, for in theater is generally implied the intent to inform, entertain, inspire, or otherwise enrich. Rather, American two party electoral politics is akin to the ongoing manipulation and suffocating gaslighting of a chronic abuser who insists upon the worst forms of oppression and control in order to maintain power.
Please understand that my argument herein is not to abandon American electoral politics, but rather to A) have a realistic understanding of where the working class stands in the face of both parties and B) pragmatic strategies for enforcing accountability on those who can still be held accountable while C) building mass movements outside the two-party system to create ample pressure for the kind of changes Americans so desperately need.
A favorite example of mine to illustrate the type of progressive, Left base building that needs to occur is through Roosevelt’s journey to passing the New Deal policies that built the overwhelming prosperity of mid-20th-century America. Roosevelt was responding to the pressures of broad working class discontent paired with the organizing efforts of formal Leftist groups such as labor unions and the Marxist-Leninist Communist Party USA (CPUSA) placing pressure on the unworkable class dynamics of 1930s America.
While Roosevelt did not pass the New Deal out of the goodness of his heart (rather describing his work as an effort to ‘save capitalism,’), and while future Left movements in America should strive for more than placation from their capitalist masters, the results nonetheless spoke for themselves. The message is clear: without organized, sustained pressure from working class movements, American power centers will not respond. The dam must be made to break.
